fbpx Skip to Content

How Adding Pudding to Cake Mix Makes It Taste Better Than Homemade

Are you looking for an easy way to make a box cake mix taste like a bakery quality cake? Adding pudding to cake mix makes the cake more moist, dense, and flavorful. It is perfect if you want a nice quality cake, but lack a lot of time or experience.

First, let me say that I love cooking from scratch. I love to know what is going into my food, but have found very few cake recipes that can stack up to a doctored boxed cake mix in flavor and moistness. Plus, it’s easy and can be really cheap if you can find the boxed mixes on sale.

baking aisle of grocery store - choosing the best cake mix

Which is the best boxed cake mix to use?

Brand names really don’t matter. I tend to buy whatever is on sale at the time.

Affiliate Disclosure
This post may contain affiliate links, which means I may receive a commission if you click a link and make a purchase. Clicking on the link will not cost you anything extra.

In general, you want a boxed cake mix and a boxed instant dry pudding mix.

If you want to really have fun with it, mix the flavors. Butterscotch pudding would be great with yellow cake mix.

I like to use French vanilla pudding mix with plain vanilla cake mix. It gives it a definite vanilla pudding flavor. It is delicious.

I stick to traditional cake flavors (vanilla and chocolate) when doing a sheet cake for a party. Although, I will say that I prefer German chocolate cake mix as opposed to regular chocolate cake. It just has a richer flavor. If I’m going to eat chocolate cake, I want it to be good.

Can I really add pudding to cake mix?

Keep in mind that you are adding the dry pudding mix, not pre-made pudding; however, pudding makes an excellent filling between layers of cake or inside of cupcakes.

What does adding pudding to cake mix do?

It is the added fat from the dry pudding mix that makes your cake mix so moist, plus the added flavor that makes it so delicious.

We add the additional oil and egg because of this added dry mix. We need the extra moisture to balance it all out.

adding pudding to cake mix | The Not So Modern Housewife

What type of oil should I use in the cake mix?

Originally, I used vegetable oil in this recipe. Now, I use coconut oil because I’m trying to get away from processed vegetable oil.

You will probably need to heat the coconut oil slightly to get it in it’s liquid form. Coconut oil has a very low melting point, so it won’t take much. Don’t get it hot, or it will cook your eggs. Mine is usually a liquid at room temp in the summer.

I’ve seen people suggest butter in place of the oil. The only problem you may have with using butter is that butter has a higher moisture content than oil. It may not be enough to really make a difference, but your cake batter will definitely be thinner.

If unrefined coconut oil has too much of a coconut flavor for you, try refined coconut oil.

How many boxes of cake mix do I need?

A 15.25 oz box of cake mix is designed to filled one 9″x13″ baking dish, which is equal to a quarter sheet pan. The added pudding doesn’t add a significant volume to the cake batter when you’re talking in terms of a sheet cake. If anything, you may end up with a few extra cupcakes.

You’ll notice the biggest difference in terms of the high of your cake. You can also add height to your cake by slicing the cake horizontally into layers and adding filling.

So as an easy reference guide, here is how much cake mix I recommend for sheet cakes:

  • Quarter sheet cake – 13″ x 9″ x 2″ – 1 box cake mix & 1 box pudding mix
  • Half sheet cake – 12″ x 18″ x 2″ – 2 boxes cake mix & 2 boxes pudding mix
  • Full sheet cake – 18″ x 24″ x 2″ – 4 boxes cake mix & 4 boxes pudding mix

You will probably need to experiment with adding pudding mix to cake mix to determine exactly how much you will need based upon the size of cake that you care baking, but this is a general guide to get you started.

Recommended Cake Baking & Decorating Tools

Here are a few tools I recommend to help with your cake and cupcake making:

Stainless Steal Mixing Bowls – the silicone bottoms make a huge difference with these bowls
Electric Hand Mixer – there’s really no point in dragging out the big mixer for a single cake mix. Save the big mixer for the icing.
9″ x 13″ Cake Pan – good size if you want a smaller sheet cake. The straight sides of this pan make the cake easy to decorate.
9″ Round Cake Pan – perfect for smaller cakes
Cupcake Tin – for standard sized cupcakes and muffins
Large Cake Decorating Tips – I consider these tips to be the basics for anyone decorating cakes and cupcakes
Decorating Tips for Details – these are great for borders, flowers, and writing
Disposable Pastry Bags – I find reusable bags too difficult to keep clean and I worry about bacteria breeding in them. I feel safer using disposable pastry bags.
Paper Mart – If you’re gifting or selling your baked goods, I’ve found Paper Mart to be a really good resource for packaging.

Pin this recipe for later:

Decorated cupcakes and cake batter in a mixing bowl with beaters - How Adding Pudding to Cake Mix Makes It Taste Homemade

Ingredients:

1 – 15.25 oz (432g) box Cake Mix
1 – 1.85 oz (52.5g) box Instant Pudding
1 extra Egg
1 extra oz oil (I use coconut oil)

Icing

Swiss Buttercream Icing

Follow the directions for the first step of the cake mix. Add the ingredients listed on the box. To add pudding mix, you will want to add the powdered mix from the box, one additional egg, and one additional ounce of oil. Using an electric mixer, mix the batter on medium speed until all of the ingredients are just incorporated.

Do not over mix your batter. It is ok to still have some lumps, but you do not want a lot of bubbles. Do not mix for more than 2 minutes.

Pour the batter into a cake pan or cupcake liners. Bake according to the directions on the back of the cake mix box. Cake is done when a toothpick inserted in the center of the cake comes out clean.

Allow the cake or cupcakes to cool completely before you apply icing.

Note: If you have concerns about the ingredients in boxed cake mix and instant pudding, Thrive Market has some great organic and gluten free options.

Doctored Cake Mix

Doctored Cake Mix

Yield: 12 Servings
Prep Time: 5 minutes
Cook Time: 20 minutes
Total Time: 25 minutes

Adding pudding to cake mix makes the cake more moist, dense, and flavorful. It is perfect if you want a nice quality cake, but lack a lot of time or experience.

Ingredients

  • 1 - 15.25 oz (432g) box Cake mix
  • 1 - 1.85 oz (52.5g) box Instant pudding mix
  • 1 extra Egg
  • 1 oz extra oil, I use coconut oil
  • icing, for decoration

Instructions

  1. Follow the directions for the first step of the cake mix. Add the ingredients listed on the box, then add in the pudding mix, one additional egg, and one additional ounce of oil.
  2. Using an electric mixer, mix the batter on medium speed until all of the ingredients are incorporated.
  3. Do not over mix your batter. It is ok to still have some lumps, but you do not want a lot of bubbles. Do not mix for more than 2 minutes.
  4. Pour the batter into a cake pan or cupcake tins. Bake according to the directions on the back of the cake mix box.
  5. Ice the cake or cupcakes after they are completely cool.

Notes

Calories and cooking times are approximate. Actual times and calorie content will vary depending upon ingredients used. Follow baking times and temperatures recommended on the cake mix package.

Nutrition Information
Yield 12 Serving Size 12 Servings
Amount Per ServingCalories 255

Aram Mart

Thursday 2nd of January 2020

We have had our fill of cupcakes this week! Hahaha. Great article, and such sweet insight into the rewards that accompany a self-made life. We're inspired! Thanks so much for mentioning Paper Mart for your bakery packaging needs. We certainly appreciate it. We added you on Social so we won't miss out. Please keep up the great work! We're looking forward to it!

Nilda

Friday 6th of May 2022

@Bonnie, how far in advance do you think is ok to make this? and should i keep at room temp (covered/ unfrosted) or refrigerated? i’d frost day of.

Bonnie

Friday 3rd of January 2020

I followed you back on Twitter. Thank you so much for finding me and stopping by. :)

Lori Wagley

Sunday 29th of December 2019

Would sugar free pudding mix work?

Bonnie

Wednesday 1st of January 2020

I don't see why it wouldn't. I think it's the added fat in the pudding that improves the cake's texture. It's certainly worth a try.

Wanda

Wednesday 13th of February 2019

If the cake mix already has pudding mix in it do you still add a pudding mix?

Wanda

Wednesday 13th of February 2019

Thanks let me know

Bonnie

Wednesday 13th of February 2019

You shouldn't have to, but I honestly haven't tried the cake mixes with pudding in them. I imagine it'll give you less volume than this recipe. You would just follow the box direction.

I'll have to make the two and compare.

Marie

Sunday 19th of August 2018

I tried this recipe yesterday for cupcakes and they turned out perfectly. Used Betty Crocker yellow cake mix and store brand instant vanilla pudding. Very happy with the taste and texture of the cupcakes!

Bonnie

Monday 20th of August 2018

Thank you. I'm glad you enjoyed it. :)

Chuppi

Saturday 26th of May 2018

Hi can I make a 2 tiered cake with 3 layers each with this hack? Will it hold up well??

Bonnie

Sunday 27th of May 2018

I usually do 2 layers, but it should hold up. It'll be more dense than straight boxed mix. You'll probably need two boxes of mix. Bake in your cake pans and slice the cakes into layers horizontally. I'm assuming you've done tiered cakes before, so you know how to support a second tier.

Skip to Recipe